Showing posts with label HNR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label HNR. Show all posts

Saturday, September 14, 2013

Thoughts on Harvest Natural Resources

From the 12-Sep-2013 M&A Call Transcript:

http://seekingalpha.com/article/1691992-harvest-natural-resources-announces-exclusive-negotiations-to-sell-company-including-venezuela-spin-off-of-remaining-assets-transcript

"As disclosed in the press release the company is currently in the process of raising capital to ensure sufficient funding for this interim period to support the assets to be spun off as well as corporate expenses. We expect the size of that capital raised will be in the $40 million and ex-corporate expenses is earmarked for Gabon and Colombia. In essence the spin-off company is capitalized initially by the remainder of the proceeds from the proposed near-term capital raise. As a result the bulk of any current capital raise will remain within the spin-off assets.

We plan to limit the current capital raised to an amount that ensures that we preserve or enhance the substantial value of the spin-off assets and allow the Company to see this process through to fruition. In that context as it relates to the prior discussion regarding proceeds, any debt we incur for the interim period will be extinguished from the sale of proceeds prior to payment for the shareholders. As a reminder, current indebtedness stands at about $79 million."

My interpretation of the M&A call:

1) If capital raise is all debt:

$373 million sale - $79 million current debt - $40 million debt from capital raise / 40 million shares outstanding = $6.35 per share plus shares in SpinCo all distributed to shareholders at the completion of the sale (assuming sale is consummated).  Indebtedness of the company will be extinguished at the close, so SpinCo would have to do another capital raise.

2) If capital raise is all equity; assuming 10 million shares issued at $4.00 per share:

$373 - $79 / 50 = $5.88 per share plus shares in SpinCo.

Both scenarios assume that the transaction will not incur any U.S. taxes (HNR's stated belief).

During the call CEO James Edmiston stated "We estimate the cash payment to the shareholders alone will be in excess of the current stock price."  It appears that purchasers of shares of HNR at the current share price of $5.10 will be paid to receive shares of SpinCo (assuming sale is consummated).  SpinCo will include the Gabon contingent resources which have an expected monetary PV10% value of $550 million with $947 million risked mean exploration value.  There is a large range of uncertainty in the value of Dussafu, but I figure that the intrinsic value of Gabon is probably worth more than the current enterprise value of HNR (~$285 million).

Disclosure: No position

Saturday, July 14, 2012

My current thoughts on Harvest Natural Resources

On June 21nd a deal was announced with Pertamina (controlled by the Indonesian government) which almost doubled the stock as I predicted. I sold half my shares and I am waiting for a better price to sell the rest. All that is really needed is approval from both the Venezuelan and Indonesian governments. The deal wouldn't have gotten as far as it has without support from both governments so I see a high probability that the deal will be consummated for approx $12 per share.

A couple of individuals, which I have great respect for their opinions, have argued that if the sale is consummated management will not use the proceeds wisely.  They believe that management overpays themselves; the sale of the Utah assets was too cheap; that the proceeds from that sale were wasted in Indonesia and Oman; and that the proceeds from the Venezuelan assets will likely be wasted too.  I do not agree.

When I read the proxy statement I see management that is compensated in accordance with industry averages.  I agreed with the decision to sell the Utah assets because the company was asset rich and cash poor and the proceeds received were reasonable in my opinion.  I also agreed that the risk/reward scenario was attractive in Oman and Indonesia.  No one would be complaining if any of those four wells was successful.  A particular sore point for critics was the two Indonesia wells that were well over budget and both failed to reach the primary Miocene objective.  Tately Budong Budong was the operator of those two wells for political reasons despite Harvest Natural Resources' 64.4% interest.  In a conference call, CEO James Edmiston stated that Tately Budong Budong had "massively underperformed" and I understood him to say that all future drilling in Indonesia with Tately Budong Budong as the operator would be restricted to the shallower Eocene targets.

Old post I made on Yahoo Message Board defending HNR management

I am going to take the lazy approach to defend HNR management and copy & paste a 01/27/10 comment from a different message board (credit REAUX1318) and add Q1 2012 info.


Current management took over the company from a bankrupt Alex Benton in 2000: "As a result of Benton's increased leverage and poor investment returns since 1998, our equity and public debt values have eroded significantly. In order to effectuate the changes necessary to restore our financial flexibility and to enhance our ability to execute a viable strategic plan aimed at creating new stockholder value, we undertook several significant actions beginning in 2000, including: Hired a new President and Chief Executive Officer, a new Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer and a new Vice President and General Counsel; Reconstituted our Board of Directors with industry executives with proven experience in oil and natural gas operations, finance and international operations; Redefined our strategic priorities to focus on value creation; Initiated capital conservation steps and financial transactions to de-leverage the company and improve cash flow for reinvestment; Undertook a comprehensive study of our core Venezuelan asset to attempt to enhance the value of its production, thus ultimately increasing cash flow and potentially extending its productive life. We continue to aggressively explore means by which to maximize stockholder value. We believe that we possess significant producing properties in Venezuela which have yet to be optimized and valuable unexploited acreage in Venezuela and Russia. The intrinsic value of our assets is burdened by a heavy debt load and constraints on capital to further exploit such opportunities." http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/845289/000095015201002063/l86922ae10-k.txt


Let's see how the current management team has done since joining the company in 2000 (and after the Venezuela nationalization which began in early 2006):

Select Balance Sheet Data

2000
Cash+Restricted Cash $26 million
Long-Term Debt $213 million
Current Liabilities $51 million
Cumulative Stock Buybacks $0
Shareholders Equity $13 million
Shareholders’ Equity Per Share $0.42
Basic Shares Outstanding 30.7 million
Diluted Shares Outstanding 30.9 million

2005
Cash+Restricted Cash $163 million
Long-Term Debt $0
Current Liabilities $62 million
Cumulative Stock Buybacks $0
Shareholders Equity $297 million
Shareholders’ Equity Per Share $8.05
Basic Shares Outstanding 36.9 million
Diluted Shares Outstanding 38.4 million

3Q2009

Cash+Restricted Cash $49 million
Long-Term Debt $0
Current Liabilities $19 million
Cumulative Stock Buybacks $62 million
Shareholders Equity $322 million
Shareholders’ Equity Per Share $9.70
Basic Shares Outstanding 33.2 million
Diluted Shares Outstanding 33.5 million

1Q2012
Cash+Restricted Cash $35 million
Long-Term Debt $0
Current Liabilities $36 million
Cumulative Stock Buybacks $62 million
Shareholders Equity $381 million
Shareholders’ Equity Per Share $10.19
Basic Shares Outstanding 37.4 million
Diluted Shares Outstanding 37.4 million

This does not look like value destroying management to me.

Saturday, June 23, 2012

HNR worth $19 per share?

http://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-06-21/harvest-natural-to-sell-venezuela-stake-to-pertamina

I am not sure about the quote "This deal is going to close 100 percent", but the rest of the article is correct in my view.  With the stock currently around $9 per share, the market has some doubts whether the deal will close.  I sold half yesterday and I am waiting for a better share price to sell the rest.

Thursday, June 21, 2012

Big Win for Stan's Investment Blog!

About a month a ago I published the following article saying that HNR will probably double in a couple of months

http://www.gurufocus.com/news/177596/harvest-natural-resources-will-probably-double-in-a-couple-of-months

Today it was announced that a sale for $525 million is pending.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-06-21/harvest-natural-to-sell-venezuela-stake-to-pertamina.html?cmpid=yhoo

I really stuck my neck out publishing an article with such a brash headline, so I feel entitled to say the following:

I TOLD YOU SO!!!!!!

Friday, April 20, 2012

Harvest Natural Resources' article

I found a great article that matches my thinking on HNR.  Key points:
 
1) HNR has been in exclusive negotiations for the sale of the Venezuelan assets since 6 Mar 2012.
2) Management has made it clear that "There will be no fire sale" and has also made it clear that a sale equal to the current share price would be a fire sale.  (For what it is worth, I like and trust management.)
3) Negotiations are going fine and are on-going.  A sale is not guaranteed, but seems likely.  $15 per share sale price sounds about what management would accept (verses current $6.27 share price).
4) If sale does not occur, the downside from here is minimal.  No sale could even be a blessing in disguise if Chavez loses the election or dies of cancer.
 
I am cautiously optimistic.  Looks like a very good risk/reward scenerio

http://www.littlebear.us/harvesting-venezuelan-oil-the-bull-case-for-hnr/